
AutoCAD2011ProductivityStudy
2 ©2010DavidS.Cohn
ComparisonofUserProductivityBetween
AutoCAD2008andAutoCAD2011
ByDavidS.Cohn
ExecutiveSummary
Whiletheoverallperformanceofasoftwareprogramorhardwareplatformcanbemeasuredusingstandard
benchmarks,actualuserproductivityisamoredifficultmetrictogauge,sinceitoftenincludesperceptionsof
theoveralluserexperienceandmustaccountfordifferencesinthemethodsemployedwhileusingthe
software.
In
ordertoquantifythepotentialproductivityimprovementatypicaluserislikelytoexperiencewhen
upgradingtothelatestversionofAutoCAD®,wedevisedaseriesoftestsinvolvingtimingtherepeatedre‐
creationofaselectionofdrawingsusingbothAutoCA D2008andAutoCAD2011.Thedrawingsusedwere
judgedtoberepresentativeofthosethatwouldbeproducedbytypicalAutoCADusers.
ThetestswereperformedbyDavidCohn,widelyrecognizedasanexpertintheuseofAutoCAD,utilizingthe
featuresandfunctionshejudgedtobethemostexpedientmeansofproducingtheendresultineach
respectiveversionofthesoftware.Thesoftwarewasrunoncomputerhardwareandoperatingsystemstypical
ofwhatwaslikelytobeemployedbyanactualcustomer.
0:00
2:24
4:48
7:12
9:36
12:00
14:24
Auto CAD2008 AutoCAD2011 AutoCAD2011and
newworkstation
Time(hours:minutes)
TimetoComplete
Theresultsofthestudywerequitedramatic.Ittooknearly13.5hourstocompletetheeightdrawingsusing
AutoCAD2008comparedto9.25hourstocompletethesameeightdrawingsusingAutoCAD2011.This
representsanimprovementinoveralluserproductivityof31percentasaresultofupgradingfrom
AutoCAD
2008toAutoCAD2011,withoutanychangeinthecomputeronwhichAutoCADwasrun.Whenthe
workstationwasalsoupgradedtoamoremodernsystemrunningWindows®7,thetimerequiredtocomplete
theeightdrawingswasfurtherreducedto7.5hours,animprovementinoveralluserproductivity
of44
percent.
Whilenotconsideredinthequantitativeresultsofthisstudy,additionalfunctionalityavailablewhenrunning
Windows7couldfurtherimproveoverallproductivity.
Althoughtheresultsreportedinthisstudywouldlikelyvarydependingonthelevelofexperienceoftheuser
andthenatureofthedrawingsbeing
produced,similarimprovementsinpersonalproductivityarelikely,due
toimprovementsinthefeaturesandfunctionalityavailableinAutoCAD2011comparedtoAutoCAD2008.This
levelofimprovementinpersonalproductivityissosignificantthatmostuserswillfinditeasilyjustifiesthecost
ofupgrading.
Comentarios a estos manuales